Retrospective
InNoWest TransferTalk on Impact-Oriented Research Management
The TransferTalk on the 14th of October 2026 focused on the topic of "Impact-oriented research management". The three speakers presented findings and ongoing work from the working group on impacts at the Gesellschaft für Transdisziplinäre und Partizipative Forschung (GTPF). The presentation was followed by a lively discussion.
The three speakers, Dr Maximilian Räthel (Akademie für Raumentwicklung in der Leibniz-Gemeinschaft – ARL), Dr Zinaida Vasilyeva (science and technology researcher) and Dr Ilka Roose (project coordinator for InNoWest at the HNE) presented some findings from the relevant GTPF working group on impacts, as well as work currently in progress. The presentation was followed by a lively discussion.
What remains when a project ends?
Maximilian Räthel opened the talk with key questions that ran through the discussion, including:
- How can findings and impacts be secured in the long term, even beyond the project’s duration?
- What structures are needed to ensure that project experiences are further developed at an institutional level?
He also introduced the Society for Transdisciplinary and Participatory Research Gesellschaft für Transdisziplinäre und Partizipative Forschung (GTPF).
The multi-level model
Dr Ilka Roose then presented the multi-level model from the Handreichung „Wirkungsorientiertes Forschungsmanagement“. The model serves to raise researchers’ awareness of societal impact and illustrates that impact planning should begin at an early stage and in a structured manner. Impact-oriented research management therefore takes place at three levels: the institutional, the research policy and the societal levels, all of which must be taken into account at the project level in order to effectively steer impact objectives, processes and criteria. The speakers explicitly do not view this model as a method, but rather as a kind of overview with which they seek to highlight the importance of a multi-level approach in research management.
A brief presentation was followed by a lively discussion.
Changing the framework
In the ensuing discussion, it became clear that, whilst many tools for ensuring continuity and evaluating outcomes have already been developed at project level, the framework conditions for long-term impact have not yet been adapted accordingly. Some key points raised during the discussion were:
- Adaptive orientation framework: Dr Zinaida Vasilyeva argued for a middle ground between normativity and flexibility that does justice to the complexity of participatory projects.
- Knowledge transfer at the University of Applied Sciences Potsdam (FHP): Cornelia Kühn reported on the FHP’s focus on knowledge transfer, for example through the Centre for Research and Transfer Services knowledge transfer professorships and the FHP-Mobil, as well as the „ttt – Transdisziplinäre Tools testen“ series. Participation in these initiatives is voluntary. Change is most likely to occur when the framework conditions change, for example through compulsory knowledge transfer training or the inclusion of knowledge transfer experience as a recruitment criterion.
- Windows of Opportunity: Stefan Raich referred to the multi-year organisational development process at the FHP and in Brandenburg. Such phases offer the chance to translate cultural change into structural changes.
- Evaluation from the outset: Andrea Prytula emphasised that evaluation is often introduced too late and should actually be factored in from the very beginning – for example, in a „Phase Zero“ prior to submitting an application. She cited the Sparkling Science project as an example, in which the scientific team remained available for consultation even two years after the project had ended. She also highlighted that practice partners often view efforts to ensure sustainability with concern that, once the project is over, the results will end up gathering dust in a drawer. A coordination office at the universities is needed to address such issues.
- The funding providers’ perspective: Dr Maximilian Räthel pointed out that the focus of structural funding lies on new development and innovation. Transforming proven projects into longer-term structures is difficult and also faces legal hurdles. Funding bodies must therefore exert pressure to bring about institutional change.
This first TransferTalk contribution of the winter semester tied in well with earlier debates on the design of impact-oriented transfer projects. Further contributions on the challenges faced by universities in cross-institutional collaborations and regional impacts will follow in the coming months.
Outlook
The next TransferTalks are scheduled for the 2nd of December (Thünen-Institut für Regionalentwicklung, to be confirmed) and the 13th of January (Dr York Kautt, University of Kassel).